Wikiversity

What you can change and what you cannot

— Gaining the wisdom to know the difference

Butterflies emerge from an amazing metamorphosis

Introduction

edit

We spend too much time and waste too much energy in futile attempts to change what we cannot change.[1] This is a major cause of frustration and other forms of anger. The rational evidence for determining what we can change and what we cannot is overwhelming, but our behavior often tries to defy this reason and logic. Behavior based on the lower two levels of the architecture for interaction model is impossible to change. Those at the upper levels can be changed. Perhaps this course can help you sort it out, reduce your frustrations, and increase your peace-of-mind.

Objectives

edit
  Completion status: this resource is considered to be complete.
  Attribution: User lbeaumont created this resource and is actively using it. Please coordinate future development with this user if possible.

The objectives of this course are to help you:

This course is part of the Emotional Competency curriculum. This material has been adapted from the EmotionalCompetency.com page on What You Can Change and What You Cannot, with permission of the author.

If you wish to contact the instructor, please click here to send me an email or leave a comment or question on the discussion page.

What you can change and what you cannot Audio Dialogue

Things You Can Change

edit

Why waste time in futile attempts to change what you cannot, when there are so many things you can change? Here is a partial list of what you can change.

What you do:

edit
 
Leaves change to wonderful autumn colors.

What you communicate to others:

edit
  • What you say, how you say it, who you say it to, and when you say it,
  • The authenticity of your expression,
  • Your use of dialogue,
  • Who you greet, and how you greet them,
  • Facial expressions, body language, gestures, posture,
  • Grooming, dress, and personal hygiene,
  • The attitude you project,
  • What you write, say, and share,
  • The falsehoods you choose to advance,
  • The gossip you spread,
  • The rumors you spread,
  • Who you include and who you exclude,
  • Your public image,
  • The topics you avoid, and those you engage, when you are patient, when you show impatience.
  • Authentic information or deceptive, manipulative, incomplete, or disingenuous disinformation.
  • The promises you make, when you say “Yes”, and when you say “No”.
  • Who you like, who you trust, who you dislike, who you distrust,
  • Your loyalties,
  • The symmetry of the power relationships, including: deference, respect, fawning, condescension, leadership, or disrespect.
  • Who you show respect to and who you are disrespectful of,
  • What you are willing to tolerate, and what you take a stand on,
  • Who you interrupt and who you allow to interrupt you.
  • The trust you extend and the trust you earn.

What you know:

edit
  • Facts you have gathered,
  • Understanding,
  • The evidence you consider,
  • The theory of knowledge you use to choose your beliefs.
  • The beliefs you hold.
  • Expertise, skills, and how you apply your talents,
  • Literacy, logic, quantitative skills, domain knowledge,
  • What you study, read, listen to, and learn,
  • What you question and what you accept,
  • Your self-image, including your understanding of your authentic self.

How you think:

edit

What you hope, dream, and aspire to:

edit

Assignment

edit
  1. Based on the lists above, identify things you can change that would improve your well-being.
  2. Choose one or two things from the above list you would like to change.
  3. Make those changes.

Things You Cannot Change

edit
 
We need to accept those things we cannot change.

You cannot change: the past, your history, the laws of physics, facts, the weather, human nature (yours or others), personality traits (yours or others), another person's beliefs or thoughts (unless they choose to change), someone who doesn't want to change, who you are related to, human needs, sexual orientation, your talent, and things you do not acknowledge.

Don't waste time and energy trying to change these things. Recognize and accept what you cannot change and move on with your life. Perhaps this amusing story can help you decide when it is in your best interest to change course and yield to an immovable object or accept some permanent condition.

Being clear about those things you cannot change can help you accept the limitations of the law of attraction, mind over matter, the power of positive thinking, and even thoughts and prayers. This can help you avoid distractions and focus on what you can change.

Assignment

edit
  1. Based on the lists above, identify things you cannot change that you have not yet accepted.
  2. Let them go.

Things you may be able to change

edit

Although the scope of your mental state is limited to your mind, it can provide new insights and influence your attitudes, motivations, and actions. You can reframe a problem as an opportunity, or an ordeal as an adventure. You can choose optimism, hope, enthusiasm, grit, determination, practice, creativity, and resourcefulness.

You may be able to change another person's behavior if they decide they would like your help in making a change they have decided to work on. Perhaps you can influence them.

Partners in any relationship respond very differently to being trusted, respected, and treated kindly that they do to being insulted, offended, ignored, or diminished. Your actions are likely to be reflected, and often amplified, throughout a relationship. You can change the nature of the relationship by demonstrating generosity, kindness, empathy, respect, and other pro-social values.

You may be able to change social constructs.

The history of reform movements demonstrates the powerful and lasing effects that determination combined with effective and prolonged actions can have. Abolition of slavery, women’s suffrage, child labor reform, the civil rights movement, and the gay rights movements all demonstrate the power of turning ideas into action.

Habits and other behavior caused by classical conditioning or operant conditioning can be extinguished by systematic exposure to carefully chosen stimulus and carefully controlling your response.

A competent counselor or therapist may be required to assist in overcoming depression, other mood disorders, phobias, addictions, and entrenched habits. Techniques such as Cognitive Behavior Therapy and Cognitive Processing Therapy may be effective.

The placebo effect describes a surprising link between mental states and physical outcomes. In general, placebos can affect how patients perceive their condition and encourage the body's chemical processes for relieving pain and a few other symptoms but have no impact on the disease itself.

Assignment

edit

Complete the Wikiversity course on Exploring Social Constructs.

Vital Distinctions

edit

You can change what you want, but you cannot change what you need.

You can elevate your mood, but you cannot levitate your body. The Stockdale Paradox reminds us that real hope yields to evidence and is constrained by reality.

You cannot change another person, but you can change how you treat them, how you react to them, your opinions and judgments of them, and your relationship with them.

You cannot change the past, but you can reappraise, apologize, forgive, let go, take responsibility for yourself, learn, purge introjected regulations, change the present and the future, and move forward.

Missteps

edit

Vigorous attempts by powerful people to exert their will to change facts are often chaotic and costly. Here are some famous examples.

The pope was adamant that the earth ought to be the center of the universe. Galileo found convincing evidence that the earth is orbiting the sun. In a famously audacious attempt to preserve what the pope believed ought to be true, the Pope persecuted Galileo. Eventually reality prevailed, what is true ignored what the Pope believed ought to be true. Unaware of any of this, the earth circles the sun before, during, and after that historic disagreement entirely independent of what the pope thought ought to be true.

More recently, former President Donald Trump worked long and hard to overturn the results of the 2020 United States presidential election. Although his efforts so far have failed, his actions resulted in a crowd storming the United States capital, and his second impeachment.

Brute facts remain unchanged regardless of your beliefs, wishes, or proclamations. Reality is our common ground.

Locus of Control

edit

If you do poorly on a college exam, how do you explain the bad outcome? Perhaps you think: “I did not study long and hard enough. I did not ask clarifying questions in class or seek out the teacher after class. I did not review my notes in depth, this is my fault”. Or you might think: “The teacher is bad and does not care, he does not explain the material or answer questions. The author of the text book is worse; he couldn't write clearly to save his life. Also, why was the test given at 8 am the Friday before the big weekend? Clearly the teacher is to blame.” Finally you might attribute it all to fate and bad luck: “This was just not meant to be. There is nothing I could have done to prevent this outcome. I just seem to get all the bad luck. What can I do?”

This example illustrates the three possible modes or tendencies people have for attributing locus of control—where you tend to assign causes for events in your life. The first example, “I am responsible” is typical of an internalizer. The second, “It is the teacher's fault”, is typical of an externalizer, and the final example, “it is all just luck” is typical of someone who attributes events to chance. In fact, most outcomes actually result from a combination of internal and external causes, and perhaps some chance. However, each of us will tend toward one of these three styles: internalizer, externalizer, or chance, as we explain events. People who are high in the personality trait of conscientiousness tend to be internalizers and take personal responsibility for events, good or bad. People low in conscientiousness tend to be externalizers or attribute it all to chance; it is not their responsibility. Each of these viewpoints are examples of the fallacy of the single cause. Because many causes typically contribute to any outcome, the best determination comes from a careful analysis of the evidence.

A careful analysis of cause and effect can help determine what you can change and what you cannot. Internalizers may be trying to change what they cannot. They may be taking responsibility for events, good or bad, that are out of their control. Externalizers may be frustrated by feeling they cannot change anything and be quick to blame others. They may be avoiding responsibility and overlooking opportunities they have to make useful changes. People who attribute it all to chance are powerless, playing the victim, acting helpless, and behaving like they don't have any choices. The authentic response is based on an accurate knowledge of who you are and what you are capable of controlling. Strike a realistic balance between arrogance—it is all because of me, and victim—there is nothing I can do.

Assignment

edit
  1. Recall a time when you blame others for some misfortune.
  2. Reframe the event from the viewpoint of an internal locus of control.
  3. Recall a time when you blame yourself for some misfortune.
  4. Reframe the event from the viewpoint of an external locus of control.
  5. What story is more accurate?

Agency

edit

Agency is your ability to act and get things done. It is your ability to influence people, organizations, and events around you. Agency is exercising your personal power to apply your assets, including nonverbal communication, motility, mobility, physical strength, courage, resilience, creativity, ethos, facts, reason, information, talents, experience, problem solving skills, communication skills, rhetoric, dialogue, speaking truth to power, blowing the whistle, resisting opposing efforts, interpersonal skills, emotional competency, negotiating skills, conflict resolution, organizational skills, friends and other affiliations, social capital, personal network, alliances, wealth, status, positional power, and various other sources of influence, persuasion, and power.

President Theodore Roosevelt was fond of saying "Do what you can, with what you've got, where you are." That is agency.

Agency is your ability to effect change. Agency is related to an internal locus of control. Choosing to exercise agency is the ethical alternative to choosing to play the victim with the intent of manipulating others.

Rely on moral reasoning and exercise agency only for the good.

Assignment

edit
  1. Identify something you would like to change. Ensure the change you are seeking is for the good.
    1. Optionally, complete the course on Problem Finding.
  2. Identify the assets available to you that can be mobilized to effect that change.
    1. Optionally, complete the course on Solving Problems.
  3. Exercise your agency to effect that change.

Social Transformation

edit

Our world is transformed by a long tradition of social, political, and economic activism. The rise of democracy, religious freedom, abolition of slavery, woman’s suffrage, civil rights, women’s rights, LGBT rights, and human rights protections are magnificent results of people envisioning a brighter future and acting to improve our social, cultural, and political institutions. You can be part of on-going work to advance human rights worldwide, evolve governments, protect the environment, promote peace, and address the grand challenges.

Ambivalence

edit

Do you want to stop smoking or not? On the one hand you understand the health risks, costs, filth, growing opposition, and inconvenience of smoking. On the other hand however, you have smoked for years, enjoy the calm it creates, immerse yourself in the rituals it provides, identify with it, and have been physically unable to stop each time you have tried. You have denied the harm, distorted the facts, indulged in confabulation, and almost convinced yourself that smoking is good for you. This is the essence of ambivalence—literally “both feelings”—torn between wanting to change and not wanting to change. Ambivalence is very common; losing weight, seeking medical treatment, changing jobs, limiting drinking or gambling, dumping your boyfriend, getting more exercise, changing jobs, and buying a new car all invite mixed emotions.

Resolving ambivalence is the first step toward change.[2] People do not change when they are stuck in ambivalence. Clarifying the discrepancy between alternatives is essential for resolving ambivalence. When people assess for themselves the benefits of change over the status quo, they begin to resolve their ambivalence. When we can clearly see for ourselves the benefits of the new path over the old we become ready for change. The choice has to originate from within; attempts to coerce change typically fail.

People change when they are ready, willing, and able to. People are willing to change when they firmly decide to leave the past behind and make a new future. This happens when they understand the discrepancy between their goals and their present state and they autonomously choose to close that gap. They overcome denial and resistance and now are committed to the new outcome. People are able to change when they believe they are competent to perform the work necessary for the change. People are ready to change when the change becomes very important to them; when this is their highest priority.

Assignment

edit
  1. Identify some condition in your life you are ambivalent about.
  2. Work to resolve your ambivalence.
  3. Act based on this clarity.

Regret

edit

We all make mistakes and when we reflect on our lives, we may identify mistakes we regret. These mistakes often represent some loss or hurt to ourselves, people we care about, and perhaps even people we have never met.

Regret is often painful. If we ruminate and brood on the mistakes we made, replay over and over again the bad choices we made, wish we could have a chance to make a different choice, bemoan the lost opportunity, blame ourselves for not foreseeing our errors, and wallow in shame, it can be very hurtful.

What can we do with this regret? Because we cannot change the past, we cannot undo our mistakes. However, we often have an opportunity to learn, apologize, forgive, and let go.

It is useful to learn from our mistakes. It is helpful to recall the situation, the decisions we made, analyze our reasoning, the alternatives available, and consider why we made the choice we did. What can we learn from this? What can I change now and, in the future, to reduce the chances of making a similar mistake? How can this experience be used to make me a better person? Take effective action now based on what you have learned from past mistakes.

If our actions caused harm to another person, it is helpful take responsibility for contributing to this harm and to apologize fully and sincerely to all the injured parties. The Wikiversity course on apologizing provides background and guidance for apologizing. Apologize for harm you have caused.

If someone harmed you, or if you hold yourself responsible for causing some harm, then it is often useful to forgive. Forgive those who have harmed you and forgive yourself for causing harm. The Wikiversity course on forgiving provides background, guidance, and justification on forgiving.

If you have learned from your mistake, apologized to those harmed, and forgiven those who you can forgive, then your work here is done. Let go of the mistake, let go of this incident from your past, and move on.

A Buddhist Perspective on Inner Peace

edit

Buddhists believe that inner peace is the only peace, there is no other kind. What would external peace be? It is fruitless to pray for peace because it is already within you, you already have it, it cannot be given to you. Peace is only achieved by removing obstacles to it. Sanskrit prayers usually end with the chant “Om, shanti, shanti, shanti” Shanti is the Sanskrit word for “quietly” or “peace”[3].

Peace comes from removing obstacles in three areas:

  1. Disturbances from other people — you cannot change other people
  2. Disturbances not from other people (e.g. natural disasters, events in the past, today's weather)
  3. Disturbances you cause yourself — these you can change.

Understanding what you can change and what you cannot change is the simple but often difficult path to inner peace.

The Serenity Prayer

edit

The serenity prayer provides simple and profound wisdom on dealing with change. Here are some popular statements of that wisdom:

As the original prayer: God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; courage to change the things I can; and wisdom to know the difference. ~ Reinhold Niebuhr.

As a request: May I have the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; the courage to change the things I can; and the wisdom to know the difference. ~ Adaptation by Meryl Runion .

As an affirmation: I have the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; the courage to change the things I can; and the wisdom to know the difference.

Further Reading

edit

Students interested in learning more about what you can change and what you cannot may be interested in the following materials:

  • Seligman, Martin E.P. (January 9, 2007). What You Can Change and What You Can't: The Complete Guide to Successful Self-Improvement. Vintage. pp. 336. ISBN 978-1400078400. 
  • Miller, William R.; Rollnick, Stephen (September 7, 2012). Motivational Interviewing: Helping People Change. The Guilford Press. pp. 482. ISBN 978-1609182274. 
  • Johnson, Spencer (June 1, 2006). Who Moved My Cheese?: An A-Mazing Way to Deal with Change in Your Work and in Your Life. Vermilion. pp. 95. ISBN 978-0091816971. 
  • McGraw, Phil (May 6, 2003). Self Matters: Creating Your Life from the Inside Out. Free Press. pp. 336. ISBN 978-1615522637. 
  • Haidt, Jonathan; Lukianoff, Greg (September 4, 2018). The Coddling of the American Mind: How Good Intentions and Bad Ideas Are Setting Up a Generation for Failure. Penguin Press. pp. 352. ISBN 978-0735224896. 
  • Sharp, Gene (September 4, 2012). From Dictatorship to Democracy: A Conceptual Framework for Liberation. The New Press. pp. 160. ISBN 978-1595588500. 

Notes

edit
  1. ↑ This material is adapted from the EmotionalCompetency.com website with permission from the author.
  2. ↑ See, for example Motivational_interviewing
  3. ↑ https://www.yogajournal.com/practice/5-sanskrit-words-every-yogi-know
Retrieved from "https://en.wikiversity.org/w/index.php?title=What_you_can_change_and_what_you_cannot&oldid=2658447"