Open main menu

Assistant teacher course/Dialectic

DialecticEdit

Socratic debate
Activity: lecture, group work
Group size: unlimited
Preparation: ?
Instructors: 1
Duration: ?


Socratic debateEdit

The teacher cross-examines a pupil and aims to expose contradictions or inconsistencies in the pupil's propositions. The teacher formulates questions the pupil can easily admit or deny or which require the pupil to admit a contradiction or inconsistency in his propositions. It is the goal of the teacher to make it easy for the pupil to carry forward the dialog with simple answers. Teacher and pupil should agree on the dialog style beforehand and the pupil should readily follow the direction of the teacher.

...

ToDo: The "Example propositions" should be simple, considering the age of the participants. The goal is to teach a dialog style, not to present complex problems.


The handout "Example propositions" contains examples that can be used to test out the socratic method in work groups.


What did you observe while using the socratic method?

  • Did you notice, as a teacher, that you had to think more consistently about your own part of the dialog?
  • Was the dialog more effective than usual? What are the advantages?
  • Did you notice disadvantages of the socratic method?
  • Did you notice limitations of the socratic method?
  • What effect could the socratic method have on your understanding for a topic? (As a teacher or as a pupil)


Is the socratic method useful during a lesson?

  • Do the assistant teachers have the time for well-considered questioning?
  • Do the assistant teachers have the necessary knowledge and understanding in every topic?
  • Are there variants of the socratic method that may work better during a lesson?


  This resource has been released into the public domain by the copyright holder, its copyright has expired, or it is ineligible for copyright. This applies worldwide. You are advised to consider the possibility of extraterrestrial intellectual property rights claims that do require mentoring duties in compensation ("either mentoring or trouble with extraterrestrials").

Content released into the public domain may be used for any purpose without attribution, including commercial activities and creation of derivative works.