Open main menu

User:JWSchmidt/Blog/2 January 2008

This page is part of
JWSchmidt's Wikiversity blog
Feel free to add comments.
16 August 2015 - Wiki Studies
16 April 2011 - Openness
29 January 2011 - Drama Queens
13 June 2010 - Bull
5 April 2010 - Breaches
22 September - Experts
27 January - Your Banned
14 January 2009 - Wikiversity Bans
14 November - Custodianship
19 October - Review Part II
10 October - My vacation
16 September - Moulton
15 September - Forking
7 September - Distorting
27 August - Wikipedia studies
1 March 2008 - The real world
12 January - Fair Use and the GFDL
2 January 2008 - Wiki Council
---- start 2008 ----
31 December - Participatory Learning
19 December - Foundation Changes
1 December - Changing the GFDL?
13 November - What is Wikiversity?
10 November - Expert editors (part II)
14 October 2007 - Vandal Wiki
20 September - Collaborative video interface
4 September - Open Source Crusade
31 August - CheckUser
4 August - Collaborative videos
20 July - Options for video-in-wiki
1 July - Networking Web 2.0 Websites
7 June 2007 - GFDL violations
27 May - Wikiversity namespace
22 May 2007 - Wikiversity tagline
20 May - The newbie game
16 May - Tangled Hierarchies
12 May - Navigation boxes
11 May 2007 - Forced editing
9 May - Wikipedia Learning
6 May - Music collaborations
25 Mar - Reliable Sources
17 Mar - Version flagging
11 Mar - Research policy discussion
10 Mar 2007 - Credentials
3 Mar - Free media files
28 Feb - Delete or develop?
27 Feb 2007 - Main Page
25 Feb - Science and Protoscience
23 Feb - Complementing Wikipedia
21 Feb - Copyleft media files
19 Feb - Gratis versus Libre
18 Feb 2007 - Referees
16 Feb - MediaWiki interface
15 Feb - Content development projects
14 Feb - Scope of Research
13 Feb 2007 - Review Board
12 Feb - Rounded corners
11 Feb - Open vs free content
10 Feb - Research guidelines
9 Feb - Learning resource diversity
8 February - Wikiversity referees.
7 February 2007 - Wikio.
5 February - Research policy.
2 February - Portal cleanup done.
31 January - Reliable sources.
29 January - Learning projects and materials.
27 January - Recording voice chat.
25 January - Animated GIF files with GIMP.
23 January - User page cleanup.
21 January 2007 - List of portals.
20 January - 2 more portals. "Courses"
19 Jan, - Portals and templates.
18 January site statistics - 20,000 pages.
18 January - Creating and organizing portals.
17 January - Categories of Wikiversity schools.
16 Jan. - Featured content development projects.
15 January - Wikiversity status at 5 months.
14 January - The "Topic:" namespace
13 January - Featured content
13 January - Wikiversity Bugs
12 January 2007 - Start of the blog
---- start 2007 ----
24 October, 2006 - Wikiversity history
26 April, 2005 - Wiki reality games
17 March, 2004 - Semantic prosthetic
edit this list

Wiki Council

Community inputEdit

The Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees has been working to establish a professional staff that can deal with tasks like fundraising, legal challenges and technical issues related to the hardware and software that keep the wiki projects going. Indications continue to appear telling us that the Foundation and community of volunteers is just too large to rely on informal channels of communication between the community and people working at the Foundation level (Trustees and paid staff).

Special projects committeeEdit

The Special projects committee was previously established (about two years ago) as a tool for the Foundation that would involve community volunteers in the, "Evaluation, incubation, and development of current and proposed Wikimedia projects, events, and ideas". The special projects committee has several subcommittees and most of them have become inactive. An alternative idea has been the creation of a Wikicouncil. This Wikicouncil idea has been around for several years and has been imagined in several different ways. A useful summary can be found at: The foundations of the Wikimedia Foundation along with other recent related posts in the foundation-l email discussion forum. I previously tried asking Board of Trustees candidate Oscar van Dillen why he thought a Wikicouncil would be better than the Special projects committee (see the question).

Fair community representationEdit

If there were a Wikicouncil with designated community representatives, would that structure provide an efficient mechanism for allowing needs and ideas to be communicated from the community to the Foundation? Would the members of the Wikicouncil be elected in the way Trustees have been elected....by a community vote? Many people have been calling for some type of representation system that might guarantee some Wikicouncil representatives from small wiki projects (that means making sure Wikipedia is not "over-represented") and from multiple nations where a diverse range of languages are spoken (make sure that the USA and English are not "over-represented"). In any kind of a representation system, how can you make sure that small sub-communities are not shut out? It will be interesting to see how this shapes up. Hopefully all the jockeying for position will not distract from the need to have some system by which community needs can be efficiently communicated to the Foundation. How can a community-based Wikimedia Foundation not slide into having managers who are disconnected from the community?

Community representatives on the BoardEdit

I'd still like to see the promise kept that at least half of the Board will be composed of people from the community, not outside "experts". The Board appoints the Executive Director and defines the duties and powers of the Executive Director. It is important that Trustees who are active members of the community make sure that the paid staff serve the community. Also, I hope it remains clear to the paid staff that it is their job to do the work that is needed by the community. We do not need Foundation Staff who think they have the right to put their personal agendas ahead of the needs of the community. A Wikicouncil will be a waste of time if there is not an efficient organizational structure by which community needs and ideas are acted on when the Wikicouncil representatives work with the Trustees and the paid Staff.